DAE think power troweling too early is worse than waiting a bit long?
I was on a 40x60 shop slab down in Wichita last month and the guy running the crew kept yelling at me to get on it with the trowel while the bleed water was still sheening up. I told him I wanted another 20 minutes and he said I was babying it, that you gotta get on it early or you lose the finish. I bit my tongue and did it his way, and you know what happened, we got a wavy surface and two spots where the blade dug in and tore the cream. He blamed the mix, but I've poured enough to know better. My old foreman from a job in Tulsa taught me to wait until a thumbprint barely leaves a mark, and every slab I've done that way has come out flat and tight. The early guys always say you'll lose the window, but I think they're just scared of standing around. The finish doesn't lie either way, so I'd rather wait and get it right the first time than chase a torn surface with a second pass. How do you all judge when it's ready, thumbprint, foot test, or something else?