Chose the black and white Essential over the color Masterworks for my first full X-Men read and I think I picked right | Comic Book Fans - The Design Community Hub
Chose the black and white Essential over the color Masterworks for my first full X-Men read and I think I picked right
Last month I finally sat down to read the Claremont run from the start and stood in my local shop in Dayton for like 20 minutes holding both versions. Everyone online said go color Masterworks or don't bother, but those volumes cost around $100 each and the black and white Essential was $18 used. I grabbed the Essential and tore through 40 issues in a week without missing the color at all, the Byrne linework actually reads cleaner to me. Maybe I'm just cheap, but I don't think anyone needs the fancy version to get into these books. What did you all start with, cheap reprints or the pricey ones?
Did you ever flip through a color copy later to compare? I started on the cheap Essentials too and never felt like I was missing much. Black and white makes the art feel starker, which fits those early issues. Eighteen bucks versus a hundred is a no brainer.