A print shop guy in Cleveland said my palette looked 'muddy' and it stung for a week
I was working on a food truck menu board project back in February and felt pretty good about the colors I picked, warm oranges and browns for a BBQ truck. I sent it off to the print guy in Cleveland I use and he came back with one line that stuck with me: 'these all sit at the same value, nothing pops.' I didn't get it at first, so I squinted at my screen and sure enough, everything turned into one gray blob. He showed me that if I took a black and white photo of my swatches, they were all nearly the same lightness, so nothing could stand out no matter how different the hues were. I went back and dropped my background browns way darker and bumped the main orange up lighter, and suddenly the whole thing read clean from 20 feet away. Now I keep a grayscale filter handy and flip it on before I commit to anything. Does anyone else check value first before worrying about which hues go together?