Shoutout to the client who said 'just make it pop' and then sent me 19 pages of notes
Last week a guy hired me for a $1,200 logo job and his only direction was to make it pop, so I sent over three options. Two hours later he came back with a 19 page doc of notes, including a whole page about how the blue felt too corporate and another about how it needed to feel more like Apple. What got me was when he said he'd been burned by a designer before, which told me he was the common thread in all his bad jobs. I'm starting to wonder if the real flag isn't the client who gives no direction, it's the one who gives no direction and then turns into a critic overnight. How do you all screen for that before you sign anything?
Man, the "burned by a designer before" line is such a tell. Every nightmare client I've had said some version of that in the first call, and I never caught on until way too late. Here's what I want to know: when you sent those three options, did he even react to them before the 19 pages landed, or did the doc show up cold with zero hint he was unhappy? I'm asking because I've started watching how fast someone flips from "make it pop" to heavy notes, and if the notes come back that quick, I take it as a sign the guy had all that stuff in his head the whole time and just didn't say it.