A client asked me to "make the logo pop more but also smaller" and I finally get what that means
So I'm sitting in a coffee shop in Boise last Tuesday with this guy who runs a small bike repair shop, and he drops the classic line about wanting his logo bigger but also, you know, less in your face. I started to do the polite nod and file it under nonsense, but he pulled out a napkin and drew it out. He wanted the mark taller but the words tucked underneath so the whole thing took up less width. It hit me that half the vague feedback I've gotten over the years from folks paying me $200 to $800 isn't them being difficult, it's them not having the words. He's a bike guy, he thinks in frames and clearances, not in kerning and negative space. I spent two years getting annoyed at clients for this kind of talk and now I feel a little dumb about it. Thing is, I still got burned by this same guy later when he asked for 9 rounds of changes on a $400 job. How do you all pull the real ask out of a client without opening the door to endless tweaks?