Update: I redid my bakery's logo in black and white first and the counter lady picked the wrong one
I sketched the new logo in plain black and white before adding any color, and when I showed three versions to the woman who runs our counter in Boise, she pointed at the weakest one and said it was the "friendliest." Turns out color was doing all the work for the other two, so I'm redoing the shapes with no shade to hide behind. Has anyone else had a design fall apart once you stripped the color out?