Just realized my scrap pile went from a corner bin to two full barrels in 8 months, and I'm not sure if that's bad forging or good practice | Blacksmiths - The Design Community Hub
Just realized my scrap pile went from a corner bin to two full barrels in 8 months, and I'm not sure if that's bad forging or good practice
I keep a bin under my bench for offcuts and failed pieces, and back in January it was one small tub I emptied every couple weeks. Now I'm hauling out two full barrels a month to the scrapyard in Fort Worth, and I can't tell if that's because I'm actually trying harder stuff or just wasting more steel. Part of me says a real smith works closer to the finished shape and doesn't leave half a bar on the floor, the other part says you only get better by burning through stock on things that don't work out. I weighed it last month and it was 60 pounds of shorts and rejects, which felt like a lot for a guy doing this part time. So which is it, is a full scrap barrel the price of getting better, or a sign I'm sloppy with my hammer and my layout? Curious what your scrap bins look like after a normal month, and whether you count the steel you toss as part of the cost of learning.